For over two decades, Anastasio Properties has guided families through the most important decisions of their lives — with integrity, local expertise, and a commitment that goes far beyond closing day.
From your first showing to the final signature, we provide end-to-end expertise tailored to the unique Oyster Bay market.
Whether you're selling a waterfront estate or a charming colonial, our targeted marketing strategy and deep local knowledge ensure maximum exposure and top dollar.
Finding the right home is only the beginning. We negotiate fiercely on your behalf, guide you through inspections and disclosures, and protect your interests every step of the way.
Accurate pricing is everything in this market. We combine comparative market analysis with hyperlocal insights to price your property correctly from day one.
Premium properties demand premium presentation. We deliver professional photography, virtual tours, and bespoke marketing campaigns that attract serious buyers.
Moving to the North Shore? We help families and professionals navigate every detail — from school districts to commute patterns — so you feel at home from day one.
Oyster Bay's market offers unique opportunities for investors. We identify high-potential properties and provide the market analysis you need to make confident decisions.
Anastasio Properties isn't just another real estate agency — we're neighbors. Our team has called Oyster Bay home for generations, and that local DNA shapes everything we do. We know which streets hold their value through market shifts, which schools are rising, and which waterfront parcels are truly special.
When you work with us, you're not getting a transactional relationship. You're getting a partner who understands that buying or selling a home is one of life's defining moments — and who treats your goals with the seriousness they deserve.
From waterfront estates to quiet tree-lined streets, we cover the full spectrum of Oyster Bay and the surrounding North Shore communities.
Historic charm with waterfront access
Waterfront mansions and gated communities
Boat docks and bay views
Established neighborhoods near top schools
Prestigious peninsular living
Family-friendly communities with parks
The relationships we build are our greatest asset. Here's what families in Oyster Bay have shared about working with us.
"We relocated from New Jersey and felt completely overwhelmed until we met the team at Anastasio Properties. They didn't just find us a house — they helped us find our neighborhood, our school district, and ultimately, our home. The attention to detail was extraordinary."
"After 30 years in our home, selling felt daunting. Anastasio Properties made it seamless — from staging advice that doubled our asking price to handling every inspection hiccup before we even knew about it. We couldn't have asked for a better experience."
"As a first-time buyer, I was nervous about the process. My agent took the time to educate me at every step — explaining terms, showing me what to look for, and never pressuring me into anything. I felt like I had a friend in my corner the entire time."
Whether you're ready to list, looking to buy, or simply curious about your home's value — we're here. No pressure, no obligation. Just honest, expert guidance from people who know this community inside and out.
We're always happy to chat — whether you have a specific property in mind or just want to understand the current market. Reach out by phone, email, or stop by our office.
Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you within 24 hours.
Message Sent Successfully!
We'll be in touch within 24 hours.
